Rating: 5 stars ***** - Definitely a must read!
Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrel is, in the plainest words possible, a masterpiece. It's as flawless as a novel could get. Actually, I've been delaying to write this review for quite a long time now. I'm frightened I might not be able to do Clarke's wonderful novel any justice, hehe ^_^.
Strange & Norrel is a brilliantly-told tale about magic, and many other things besides: fairies, war, love, society, mystery...but to be more specific, it is chiefly about the efforts of two magicians, Gilbert Norrel and Jonathan Stange, to restore the use of magic in England. This story is blended with the events of 19th century England and the war against France. In some sense it is a historical novel, but only because Clarke used some historical figures as her characters and it echoes some events during that time. I say, Clarke is gifted with an extraordinary imagination. The book is remarkable as a historical fantasy.
Many people have claimed this book to be a Harry Potter-like fantasy for adults. But it's very different. Clarke reinvents the idea of magic, and shows its practical, social and political implications. In Clarke's world, magic is not something done for mere show. She writes it as something that means serious business, but at the same time preserving the mystery and allure of magic. She shows how magic works, and brings to light the nature of magic. Additionally, the novel features magical beings, like fairies. Fairies play a major role in the story. And again Clarke depicts them uniquely, giving them the mystical nature that is due them. This is undoubtedly one of the strongest points of Strange & Norrel: Clarke's original portrayal of the world of magic.
Strange & Norrel is also filled with wit and interesting portrayals of English society. Clarke is often compared to Jane Austen for this. But I like her better than Austen. I never got to muster enough patience to finish Pride and Prejudice, but I guess that's because there were too many run-on sentences and they hurt my brain. Which leads to another point: Clarke's sophisticated but very readable writing style. Her prose is flawless.
Her characters are well-drawn. All are realistic, all with a certain charm to them. I can't say Clarke's as good as Philip Pullman when it comes to creating great characters, but hers are good nonetheless. Especially the Raven King, one of the constant mysteries of the novel.
The book is, however, very, very long. 1006 pages. There are also many side stories of sorts in the foot notes. I think it was very creative of Clarke, but 1006 pages can be quite formidable to the not-so-patient reader. I was even a bit frightened by the book's lengthiness, actually. I would probably have enjoyed it more if I had not been. But I can't imagine the book to be as good as it is if it were shorter. I swear, though, Strange & Norrel was worth every bit of my patience. I totally enjoyed it, and I recommend it to everyone I know.
There is really much much more to say about this novel, but I think the rest can be summarized in four words: YOU. MUST. READ. IT. :D
Hannah